Lifetime has revealed its upcoming lineup of original holiday films, and while most are your typical festive rom-coms, one title stands out: a holiday thriller called Do You Fear What I Fear? Yes, the title alone is already a win.

First-look imagery was released via The Wrap, offering a sneak peek at the eerie seasonal suspense.

Here’s the official synopsis:
“When Claire (Ciarra Hanna) lands her dream job in the city, she thinks she’s finally escaped her small-town Christmas past. But when mysterious holiday decorations begin appearing in her apartment—each bearing cryptic messages from someone close to her—she must uncover the identity of her not-so-Secret Santa before it’s too late.”

Do You Fear What I Fear premieres Thursday, December 4 on Lifetime.

The network’s “It’s a Wonderful Lifetime” holiday programming kicks off November 29.